We first encounter the main character, Jerry, in the midst of football practice at the all-boys Catholic Trinity High School in the fictional town of Monument, Massachusetts. Donna Tartt’s novel The Secret History, aimed at adults, is also set on the campus of a small New England college steeped in custom and convention, and follows a new freshman as he navigates the dark underbelly of his new schoolmates’ more unsettling traditions.The Chocolate War is a story told laconically, in very short scenes and chapters, with brief dialogues and few descriptive passages. Todd Strasser’s 1981 young adult novel The Wave, in which a teacher creates a school-wide movement called “The Wave” to teach his students about the harmful but alluring rhetoric of fascist regimes, specifically Nazi Germany, but finds that his experiment goes off the rails, shares similar themes with The Chocolate War as well. Though Golding’s characters are marooned on an uninhabited island and Cormier’s are deeply entrenched in a rigid, tradition-obsessed Catholic school in New England, the parallels between the novels are astounding, and the ways in which patterns of violence, power-seeking, and coercion emerge amongst a group of young men thrust together in close quarters are explored unflinchingly in both books.

William Golding’s 1954 novel Lord of the Flies also features a group of young men, isolated from society and struggling to assert their power over one another. The Chocolate War, which deals with themes and motifs of violence, power, and masculinity-as well as coercion, groupthink, and societal oppression-is kin to several other works of young adult fiction that provide young people with a lens through which they can view and consider such big, frightening issues. The insidious corruption of Nixon’s reign coupled with the startling break from tradition his resignation signaled no doubt inspired some of the themes within The Chocolate War.

Moreover, 1974 was the year of Richard Nixon’s resignation from office, making him the first President of the United States to do so.

The question on the poster in Jerry’s locker, “Do I dare disturb the universe?”, was surely on the minds of many Americans as they reckoned with their historical moment: having come so far forward, and yet still facing down so much necessary “disturbance” in order to create even more social change and continue bettering their society. The sexual revolution, the civil rights movement, and the war in Vietnam were all fresh in the collective American memory, and the newly-granted freedoms and breaks with tradition that had taken root in society were pressed flush up against the painful repetitions of military violence, government corruption, and oppression of minority groups. The mid-1970s in America were a time of social change and even upheaval.

The chocolate war book cover